Monday, December 14, 2009

 

Crazy: Are we made that way?

"You have managed to turn me from a woman of substance, into a brick flying, calling too damn much, crying and crying, spying way down low with flats on, from the opposite side of the bar, easy off, load on the top of your car chick." -Jill Scott

A little bit tired of the image of the "crazy chick."  I would say that this construct is an overplayed media stereotype, but even in the real life conversations that I have with my guy friends, way too many of our dialogues end with, "I'm telling you ... that chick is crazy."   Where did we get saddled with this label?  Is it the few psychos who ruin it for the rest of us?  Or is it that perfectly rational women are driven to states of delirium by the antics of their significant or insignificant others (as the Jill Scott lyrics suggest)?

So the title of this particular entry is a bit of a play on words.  Is it simply in our genetic make-up to be slightly unstable, or does the behavior of men force us to states of hysteria?  Both of these explanations sound pretty sexist to me, so I'm going to vote for the couple of women who bring down an otherwise sane gender.  You all know the ones I mean - I could describe them, but it's a lot more fun to see what you have to contribute.  ;-)


Comments:
"Crazy" or irrational behavior is classic asymmetrical warfare. The most graphic example of this is a suicide bomber blowing himself up - isn't that "crazy"? So with respect to the context of your question and the relationship between men and women, the motivation behind the behavior is the same. When a person feels powerless or that they've run out of options to affect change in a rational sense, they may resort to something irrational. I'm not saying that it's fair to characterize all women in relationships as being powerless, but there is precedent for this and hence the stereotype is born.
 
I think this is a great topic to explore. I'd like to consider myself a "sane" person for the most part who is now in a very healthy, stable marriage. But I gotta be honest, even my husband made me think I was a little nuts at times when we were dating. I'm not gonna lie I did a drive-by or two at his house to make sure he was home. Not proud of it, but it happened. I think when you truly love someone, the thought of them lying or hurting you is too much to bear sometimes and can make you go crazy. I think it's okay to have those momments, as long as you come back to reality soon thereafter.
 
Rachel, interesting question. I think the problem here is that "crazy" is really a continuum. When does one transition from an "understandable" and/or appropriately "emotional" response over into crazytown? Furthermore, considering myself among the "sane" women (well, most of the time at least) I wonder if there is any reward for being level headed? It seems that once a woman starts to go off a little bit, men sit up and pay attention. Do the crazies get what they want?
 
Sadly, I voted for this one: "perfectly rational women are driven to states of delirium by the antics of their significant or insignificant others" I've seen the most stable, put-together woman driven to unspeakable acts because of a man's bad behavior. I don't think it's just a "few" women, or any particular "type" of woman. I think it's only a few women admit to it.
 
should read "who" between women & admit
 
I agree with Chiram. It's all about feeling powerless and needing to do something -- no matter how irrational -- to reclaim that power. I think men do the same thing too when they're in relationships with women who (they think) have the upper hand.
 
I'm not crazy. Sometimes irrational, sometimes neurotic but not crazy. Usually the irrational and the neurotic is brought out by intense feelings of love or fear for those I care about most. Women are what keeps the whole hold, we are strong and we are smart and although we like love and affection, we are able to survive better than men without it.

The stereotype was born and continues to thrive to make men feel better about themselves. They need their egos stroked constantly--but we (women) and they (men) know the truth, women are the stronger sex.

And no I am not some crazy, bitter lonely woman. I am a beautiful, intelligent (if I do say so myself) woman with a wonderful husband (that I've been with for over a decade). He is strong, handsome and smart and his life is made better by his amazing and sometimes irrational wife :)
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?